PC Optimum, Scene+, Blue Rewards, Costco and Triangle compared: what $10 back takes
10,000 PC Optimum points, 1,000 Scene+ points and 1,500 Blue Points are each worth $10. Costco's Executive reward is 2%, and CT Money starts at 0.4%. Here's how the big Canadian programs compare, checked November 16, 2026.
50% of our commission goes to the charity or club you pick.Change
Pick a charity and we'll give them 50% of our commission.

Every big Canadian loyalty program promises "free stuff", but the points aren't worth the same. $10 of rewards takes 10,000 PC Optimum points, 1,000 Scene+ points or 1,500 Blue Rewards points. Costco's Executive membership pays about 2% back, and Canadian Tire's base CT Money rate is 0.4%.
We read each program's own pages on November 16, 2026. We've left out the credit cards linked to these programs: they can earn more, but they're credit products with their own costs.
At a glance
| Program | Where | What $10 takes | Base earn | Paid tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PC Optimum | Loblaw stores, No Frills, Superstore, Shoppers Drug Mart | 10,000 points | 15 points per $1 at Shoppers; offers-based at grocery stores | Not confirmed |
| Scene+ | Sobeys, Safeway, FreshCo, IGA, Foodland | 1,000 points | Offers-based at Sobeys | None found |
| Blue Rewards (was AIR MILES) | Partner stores | 1,500 Blue Points | Not confirmed | Not confirmed |
| Costco | Costco warehouses and costco.ca | About $500 of purchases at 2% | Executive only: about 2% | Executive $130 a year |
| Triangle Rewards | Canadian Tire and partner gas stations | $10 of CT Money | 0.4% in CT Money | Triangle Select, $89 a year |
PC Optimum
PC Optimum's benefit table says every 10,000 points is "like $10 of free stuff". At Shoppers Drug Mart, Pharmaprix and beautyboutique.ca, the base rate is 15 points per $1, which works out to 1.5% back. At Loblaw's grocery stores, including No Frills, Superstore, Maxi and Provigo, the table shows no base earn: points come from product offers, bonus events and personalized offers in the app.
The program also runs redemption events, such as spending 10,000 points for $15 of free stuff, which make points worth 50% more if you wait for them.
Best for: Shoppers Drug Mart regulars and anyone who loads offers in the app every week.
Scene+
At Sobeys and its sister stores, Scene+ says you earn points through weekly flyer events and everyday product offers, boosted by personalized offers in the Sobeys app. Every 1,000 points is $10 off groceries, so each point is worth 1 cent. Scene+ caps earning at liquor stores at 5,000 points a day.
Best for: Sobeys, Safeway, IGA and FreshCo shoppers.
Blue Rewards, formerly AIR MILES
AIR MILES became Blue Rewards in 2026. The program's own blog says Reward Miles were converted to Blue Points "with no value lost" in summer 2026, and 1,500 Blue Points are worth $10 when redeemed in store or for eGift cards.
The main Blue Rewards site blocked our checks, so we couldn't confirm base earn rates at partner stores or the exact conversion figures. Check your balance and the earn rate at the stores you use.
Best for: people who already have a balance and shop at its partners.
Costco
Costco Canada's Gold Star membership is $65 a year plus tax, and Executive is $130. The Executive reward is about 2% of pre-tax purchases on most Costco buys, capped at $1,250 in any 12-month period. Upgrading from Gold Star costs $65 a year. Executive members also get a $10 monthly credit on Same-Day or Costco via Instacart orders of $150 or more.
Best for: households spending a lot at Costco. The worked example below shows the break-even.
Triangle Rewards
Canadian Tire's Triangle Rewards pays a base rate of 0.4% in CT Money on pre-tax purchases, and each $1 of CT Money is worth $1. At Gas+ and Essence+ stations, you collect 3 cents a litre with a Triangle Rewards card, and up to 3 cents at Petro-Canada.
Triangle Select, the paid tier, is advertised at $89 a year plus tax (the comparison tables on the same page say $89.99). It adds a 10x everyday in-store bonus, 20x on 20 selected brands and a 20x top-up on your largest in-store purchase of the year, all multiples of the base rate.
Best for: regular Canadian Tire shoppers, and drivers who fill up at Gas+.
A worked example
Costco Executive. The upgrade costs $65 more than Gold Star. At about 2%, you'd need roughly $3,250 of eligible pre-tax spending a year to earn the $65 back. A household spending $500 a month ($6,000 a year) would earn about $120, so about $55 ahead after the upgrade fee.
Shoppers Drug Mart. Spend $40 a month at the base rate and you earn 600 points a month, or 7,200 a year. That's worth about $7.20, or $10.80 if you redeem at a "10,000 points for $15" event.
Triangle Select. If you spend $1,000 a year in store at Canadian Tire, the base 0.4% earns $4 in CT Money. If the 10x everyday bonus applied to all of it, that's $40, still less than the $89 fee. On everyday bonus alone, Select pays off somewhere around $2,500 of in-store spending a year.
Where the others have the edge
- PC Optimum has the most grocery stores, from No Frills to Superstore, plus a 1.5% base rate at Shoppers Drug Mart.
- Scene+ points are simple to value at 1 cent each.
- Blue Rewards carries over old AIR MILES balances with no value lost, the program says.
- Costco Executive is the only one paying a flat 2% on most purchases without loading offers.
- Triangle pays dollar-for-dollar CT Money and adds gas savings.
What to do now
- Join the free programs for the stores you already use. There's no reason to switch stores for points alone.
- Load personalized offers in the PC Optimum and Sobeys apps each week, since that's where grocery points come from.
- Save PC Optimum points for redemption events that give more than $10 per 10,000 points.
- Before paying for Costco Executive or Triangle Select, add up last year's spending at that store and check the break-even.
- Compare shelf prices, not just points. A cheaper store with no points can beat a pricier one with them.
Questions
Which program gives the most back on groceries? It depends on offers. PC Optimum and Scene+ both reward personalized offers rather than a flat rate at grocery stores, so the value comes from the offers you actually use.
Do points expire? Each program has its own terms. Check them in your account, especially if you haven't used a card in a while.
What about Walmart and Metro? Walmart.ca and Metro's site blocked our checks, so we couldn't confirm their programs' current terms.
The verdict
For most families, the free programs at the stores you already use are worth having, as long as you load the offers. PC Optimum is the strongest if you shop at Loblaw stores and Shoppers. Costco Executive pays off once you spend about $3,250 a year there. Triangle Select only makes sense for heavy Canadian Tire shoppers. Points are a bonus: the shelf price still matters more.
Cutting other monthly bills? See our phone plan comparison.
When you shop through Promo Magpie, part of the commission the shop pays us goes to the charity or club you pick. You pay the same price.
Sources: PC Optimum, program benefit table, checked November 16, 2026, Scene+, Sobeys, November 16, 2026, Scene+, How it works, November 16, 2026, Blue Rewards blog, Meet Blue Rewards, updated June 5, 2026, Costco Canada, Join Costco, November 16, 2026, Costco Canada, Executive rewards, November 16, 2026, Triangle Rewards, November 16, 2026, Triangle Select, November 16, 2026
The Thursday email
Every Thursday: the best codes from the brands you shop at. After you sign up, pick your brands and whether you want codes, hot deals, free delivery or student offers. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.
Keep reading
Rogers and Bell vs Fido, Virgin, Koodo and Freedom: 60GB for $50 or less
The big carriers' advertised prices lean on internet bundles and autopay credits. Their own value brands and Freedom offer 60GB or more for $50 or less, if you can live without some extras. Prices checked November 16, 2026.
Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video, Apple TV and Crave compared: from $7.99 a month
The cheapest ad-supported plans start at $7.99 a month, but the ad-free tiers, extra members and bundles change the sums. Here's what each service costs in Canada, prices checked on November 16, 2026.