Skip to content

Smartwatches compared: Apple Watch from $249 vs Garmin, Pixel Watch and Galaxy Watch

Smartwatches cost $249 to $700 at the makers' own stores. Your phone decides most of it: Apple needs an iPhone, Samsung and Google need Android, and Garmin works with both and lasts days, not hours.

Pick a charity and we'll give them 50% of our commission.

A person in a white shirt wearing a smartwatch with a black band
Photo: Tyler Hendy on Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

A new smartwatch costs anywhere from $249 to $700 at the makers' own stores, before any subscription. We checked prices on Apple, Google, Garmin and Samsung's US sites on November 15, 2026. The biggest difference isn't the price. It's which phone you own, and how often you want to charge.

Prices checked on November 15, 2026. Garmin had sale prices on several watches that day, and Google says its Black Friday deals start November 19, so check again before you pay.

At a glance

WatchPrice fromBattery (maker's figure)Works withOptional subscription
Apple Watch SE 3$249Up to 18 hoursiPhone 11 or laterFitness+ $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year
Apple Watch Series 12$399Up to 24 hoursiPhone 11 or laterFitness+ $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year
Apple Watch Ultra 4$700Up to 50 hoursiPhone 11 or laterFitness+ $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year
Google Pixel Watch 5$399.99Up to 40 hoursAndroid 12.0 or newerGoogle Health Premium from $9.99 a month
Google Fitbit Air (tracker)$99.99Up to a weekAndroid 11.0 or newer, or iOS 16.4 or newerGoogle Health Premium from $9.99 a month
Garmin vivoactive 6$249.99 on sale (list $299.99)Up to 11 daysiPhone and AndroidConnect+ $6.99 a month or $69.99 a year
Garmin Venu 4$449.99 on sale (list $549.99)Up to 12 daysiPhone and AndroidConnect+ $6.99 a month or $69.99 a year
Samsung Galaxy Watch9$379.99Not stated on the page we readAndroid onlyNone listed on the pages we read
Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra2$699.99Not stated on the page we readAndroid onlyNone listed on the pages we read

Start with your phone

This decides most of it. Apple says the Apple Watch Series 12, Ultra 4 and SE 3 need an iPhone 11 or later running iOS 27 or later. Google says the Pixel Watch 5 needs a phone running Android 12.0 or newer. Samsung's US support page says Galaxy watches running Wear OS "are not compatible with iOS devices", and that they can't be used without a phone.

Garmin is the one smartwatch maker here that works with both. Its pages for the vivoactive 6, Venu 4 and Forerunner 570 say they work with the Garmin Connect app on iPhone and Android. If your household mixes iPhones and Android phones, or you might switch, that matters.

Apple Watch: $249 to $700

Apple's lineup starts with the SE 3 at $249, then the Series 12 from $399 and the Ultra 4 from $700. Battery life is the main trade-off. Apple quotes up to 18 hours of normal use for the SE 3, up to 24 hours for the Series 12 (38 hours in Low Power Mode), and up to 50 hours for the Ultra 4 (84 hours in Low Power Mode). In practice, the SE 3 and Series 12 are charge-every-night watches.

Apple Fitness+ is optional. New subscribers get one month free, or three months free when they buy an eligible device such as a new Apple Watch, then it costs $9.99 a month or $79.99 a year. You don't need it to track workouts, heart rate or sleep on the watch.

Google Pixel Watch 5 and Fitbit: $99.99 to $399.99

The Pixel Watch 5 starts at $399.99 in 41mm and 45mm sizes. Google quotes up to 40 hours of battery, and 15 hours from 15 minutes on its Quick Charge Dock. Google is including three months of Google Health Premium with the watch, and Premium starts at $9.99 a month after that. The Fitbit app is now called the Google Health app.

If you mainly want activity and sleep tracking, Google's Fitbit Air tracker band costs $99.99, with up to a week of battery according to Google. Unlike the Pixel Watch, it works with iPhones too: Google lists Android 11.0 or newer, or iOS 16.4 or newer.

Garmin: days, not hours

Garmin's watches last far longer between charges. Garmin quotes up to 11 days for the vivoactive 6, up to 12 days in smartwatch mode for the Venu 4, and up to 10 days for the Forerunner 570 running watch. That's the main reason runners, hikers and people who track sleep tend to pick one.

Garmin had sales on when we checked. The vivoactive 6 cost $249.99 against a list price of $299.99. The Venu 4 cost from $449.99 against a list price from $549.99, and the Forerunner 570 cost $449.99 against $549.99. Sale prices can end at any time.

Garmin Connect+ is the optional paid tier, at $6.99 a month or $69.99 a year.

Samsung Galaxy Watch: $379.99 to $699.99

Samsung's Galaxy Watch9 starts at $379.99 for the 40mm Bluetooth model, with larger and LTE versions listed up to $459.99. The Galaxy Watch8 Classic, with its rotating bezel design, starts at $499.99, and the Galaxy Watch Ultra2 is $699.99. Samsung's own page tells you to "pair it with your Galaxy phone", and its support page confirms these Wear OS watches don't work with iPhones.

Samsung was also running trade-in credit offers on its watch pages. Read the terms: Samsung says if a trade-in doesn't meet its requirements, you're charged back the credit minus $25.

What it costs over two years

Here's a worked example for someone who wants coaching or workout classes, using the prices we found on November 15:

  • Apple Watch Series 12 plus Fitness+: $399, three free months with the watch, then two yearly payments of $79.99 = $558.98.
  • Pixel Watch 5 plus Google Health Premium: $399.99, three free months, then 21 months at $9.99 ($209.79) = $609.78.
  • Garmin Venu 4 on sale plus Connect+: $449.99 plus two years at $69.99 = $589.97.

Skip the subscription and the gap closes to the watch price alone. Most people can.

Where the others have the edge

  • Apple is the only choice here if you want full smartwatch features on an iPhone, and the SE 3 at $249 is the cheapest full smartwatch in this list.
  • Garmin wins on battery by a distance, and it's the only full smartwatch range here that works with both iPhone and Android.
  • Google has the cheapest way in, with the $99.99 Fitbit Air tracker that also works with iPhones, and the Pixel Watch 5's 40 hours beats Apple's Series 12 on paper.
  • Samsung makes sense if you already own a Galaxy phone, with the Watch9 from $379.99 undercutting both the Series 12 and Pixel Watch 5.

What to do now

  1. Check which phone you'll have for the next two or three years. That rules out most of the list.
  2. Decide how often you'll charge. Nightly charging is fine for some people and a deal-breaker for sleep tracking.
  3. Try the free features before paying for Fitness+, Health Premium or Connect+. Set a reminder before any free trial ends.
  4. Compare the maker's price with what the big retailers charge once their Black Friday sales start.
  5. If you're buying a gift, check the return window covers the holidays.

Questions

Can I use an Apple Watch with an Android phone? No. Apple says these models need an iPhone 11 or later.

Can I use a Galaxy Watch with an iPhone? No. Samsung says Galaxy watches running Wear OS are not compatible with iOS devices.

Do I need a cellular (LTE) model? Only if you want calls and data without your phone nearby. LTE versions cost more to buy, and your carrier may charge to add a watch to your plan, so ask before you choose one.

Is a smart ring an alternative? For sleep and recovery tracking without a screen, yes. You lose notifications and on-wrist workouts.

Ways to save

If you'd rather skip the screen altogether, Ultrahuman makes smart rings, and our page lists its trade-in deal of up to $115 off a new ring when you trade in your old one, plus a free sizing kit. Codes and deals can change, so check the page before you buy. Planning bigger tech buys too? Our guide to checking a Black Friday "was" price shows how to tell whether a sale is real.

When you shop through Promo Magpie, part of the commission the shop pays us goes to the charity or club you pick. You pay the same price.

Sources: Apple, Buy Apple Watch, Nov 15 2026, Apple Watch Series 12, Nov 15 2026, Apple Watch Ultra 4, Nov 15 2026, Apple Watch SE 3, Nov 15 2026, Apple Fitness+, Nov 15 2026, Google Store, Pixel Watch 5, Nov 15 2026, Google Store, Fitbit Air, Nov 15 2026, Google Store, Google Health Premium, Nov 15 2026, Garmin, vivoactive 6, Nov 15 2026, Garmin, Venu 4, Nov 15 2026, Garmin, Forerunner 570, Nov 15 2026, Garmin Connect+, Nov 15 2026, Samsung, Galaxy Watch9, Nov 15 2026, Samsung, Galaxy Watch8 Classic, Nov 15 2026, Samsung, Galaxy Watch Ultra2, Nov 15 2026, Samsung, Galaxy watches, Nov 15 2026, Samsung US support, Nov 15 2026

Ad: affiliate links. The codes and deals below link to the stores, and we may earn a commission if you buy, at no cost to you. How we make money.

Save on this

Codes & deals for this story

The Thursday email

Every Thursday: the best codes from the brands you shop at. After you sign up, pick your brands and whether you want codes, hot deals, free delivery or student offers. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

We'll email you a link to confirm and choose what you get. We only use your email for the emails you ask for. Privacy policy.

Keep reading

Pick a charity or club to support · we give it 50% of our commission, at no cost to youChoose